The Competition Act of 2023 is significant because it makes a number of key changes to the competition law in India. The amendments to the Competition Act of 2002 have been made by the government to modernise the competition law to keep pace with fast-changing technological and global business environments. The amendments provide for a more rigorous enforcement of competition laws, a more efficient regulatory system, and ensure that there is equitable competition among various sectors.
What the Amendment Will Focus On
The Competition (Amendment) Act of 2023 is an update to the Competition Act of 2002 and aims to make the regulations surrounding anti-competitive agreements, abuse of dominance, mergers, and acquisitions more efficient and effective in India.
In other words, the amendments will make competition law in India faster, stricter, and more in tune with the realities of the modern economy. Through these amendments, the Competition Commission of India now has greater power and capabilities to comprehensively assess complicated transactions and competently address unethical business practices in the marketplace.
Why Was This Act Introduced?
The Indian market has gone through significant changes since 2002. Digital platforms have become the leading players in the market, as have online marketplaces and technology-driven businesses. However, before the 2023 amendment, India’s laws did not adequately deal with: digital acquisitions of high value; foreign companies with little or no revenue generated from India; prolonged time frames for investigations; lack of a viable deterrent due to the low level of penalties imposed.
The 2023 amendment was enacted to: respond to the unique challenges presented by digital and data-driven marketplaces; expedite investigations and approvals through the introduction of a fast-track process; reduce the potential for prolonged litigation; enhance current penalties; and ensure that Indian competition law is consistent with international standards.
The ultimate goal of the 2023 amendment is to protect consumers and foster fair competition throughout India.
Who Does It Apply To?
The Competition (Amendment) Act of 2023 covers the following categories of entities:
– Indian and non-Indian companies carrying out business in India
– Technology companies and digital platforms
– Startups that are party to a merger or acquisition
– Business organisations, as well as other business-related organisations
– Individuals who are participating in an anti-competitive practice, or who have participated in a cartel
– The Competition Commission of India (CCI)
– Any party who has filed an appeal with the NCLAT
– Any entity whose conduct might impact competitors’ ability to compete with one another in India’s marketplace.
Each entity referenced above is subject to the provisions of the Competition (Amendment) Act of 2023.
What Are the Key Provisions?
Here’s a simplified summary of the significant changes made by the amendments of 2023 as follows:
1) New Threshold for Reporting Deal Value – The threshold for reporting composite deals has changed. All combinations over a certain deal amount must be submitted to the CCI for review, whether or not they exceed the asset or revenue thresholds. This is an important change, especially for the acquisition of digital and start-up companies
.
2) Shortened Timeframe for Approval – The amount of time it takes for the CCI to respond to combination requests has been reduced, which allows for quicker decision-making on behalf of companies.
3) Resolution of Disputes through Settlement or Commitment – Parties being investigated for engaging in certain types of anti-competitive behaviour can offer the CCI a settlement or commitment, which should allow for quicker resolution of disputes.
4) Global Penalty Based on Turnover – Companies may now be penalised based upon their total global turnover rather than just local turnover, which will make fines more cost-effective, and it should discourage violations.
5) Leniency Plus – Members of a cartel that provide the CCI with evidence or additional information regarding other cartels may receive additional reductions in penalties.
6) Recognition of Hub-and-Spoke Cartels – Indirect arrangements between cartels (hub and spoke) are specifically addressed in legislation.
7) Limitation Periods for Investigations – There are time limits on investigations into potential violations of the Act and how proceedings unfold, thereby eliminating unnecessary delays.
How Does It Work in Practice?
In practice, the amended Act operates as follows:
1. All high-value Transactions must be notifiable to the CCI
2. The CCI has a shorter time frame to investigate and review such transactions
3. Companies must now conduct their investigations on a time-bound basis
4. Companies that wish not to go through a lon,g drawn-out litigation process may choose to be affected by the CCI
5. Companies, whose orders were made by the CCI, have a right to appeal to the NCLAT against that order.
This change to the law creates a more efficient method of enforcement and, therefore, greater protection for businesses.
What are the Implications for the Company?
The above amendment has an immediate effect on the Company/Individual as follows:
1. Each Company must evaluate its current compliance strategy
2. Digital companies are expected to face greater regulatory scrutiny
3. Companies will be at much higher risk (financially) if they violate the law, due to higher penalties
4. Due to a quicker resolution of issues, the potential costs of litigation will decrease
5. Company representatives involved in cartels will face stricter penalties
As a result, all corporations will have a greater incentive to operate more responsibly and transparently.
Example
The Scenario: A Foreign-Based Technology Company Acquires an Indian-Based Start-Up At An Extremely High Price With A Very Low Revenue Base.
After The Passage of The Competition (Amendment) Act.
Transaction Moves Over The Deal Value Threshold For The CCI To Examine The Transaction Requires Approval From The CCI.
The Review Period For CCI Provides A Faster Review Process For The CCI To Complete Their Review Process Within An Accelerated Time Frame.
In The Event CCI Has Issued An Order And Is Now Reviewing, The Issuer Can Offer Commitments To The CCI. In This Manner, The Act Provides A Mechanism To Protect Competition In Modern Digital Transactions.
Why Is The Competition (Amendment) Act, 2023 Important?
The Competition (Amendment) Act, 2023, Is Important For NCLT And NCLAT Matters In Relation To NCLT And NCLAT Matters Because Appeals Against The CCI Orders Are Still Filed With The NCLAT.
- Since CCI Review Periods Are Broader, This Should Result In Fewer Judicial AppealsSettlements In CCI Cases Are Likely To Result In Lower Levels Of Litigation. Higher Penalty Amounts In Appeals Mean Higher Amounts Of Penalty Risk To The Appellant. More Explicit Language In The Act Will Assist Tribunals In Understanding The Language Of The Act.
The Changes Create A Stronger Competition Enforcement System Compared To The Current Systems.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1. Does the 2023 Amendment mean that the Competition Act, 2002, has been replaced?
No, it amends and strengthens the Competition Act (2002) but does not replace it.
Q2. Is the law strictly aimed at digital companies?
The law covers all industries but has a strong focus on digital sectors.
Q3. Are companies allowed to settle competition cases?
Yes, there is now the ability to settle certain types of competition cases.
Q4. Are the penalties higher under the new laws?
Yes, penalties will now be based on global turnover instead of just local turnover.
Q5. Where can a person appeal a decision from the CCI?
A person may appeal a decision made by the CCI to the NCLAT (the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal).
Leave a Reply